Toedter works from an imposing 6'9", 240-pound frame that creates natural deception and makes the baseball genuinely difficult to pick up out of the hand. His fastball sits 90–92 and has touched 94, playing up because of his release height and approach angle — hitters are not picking it up from a conventional slot, and that matters at every level.

He shows feel for both secondary offerings. The slider gives hitters a different glove-side look off the fastball with tight, late break. The splitter is an emerging third weapon — sitting 78–80 with 11.7 inches of horizontal fade — giving him an additional put-away option against opposite-handed bats and a pitch that plays off the elevated fastball in a way breaking balls cannot.

Toedter's size and release characteristics create immediate discomfort before the ball ever leaves his hand. The delivery is not fully refined yet — there is still developmental projection in his mechanical efficiency that, when cleaned up, could allow him to access additional velocity without requiring further physical growth. The frame is already physically mature. The delivery catching up to it is the next step.

Toedter's strongest attributes are command, pitchability, and consistency. As a freshman at Temple College, he posted a 3.18 ERA while issuing only nine walks across 22.2 innings — a walk rate that reflects a pitcher with a mature feel for the zone well ahead of his experience level. In conference play specifically, he was dominant: 1.32 ERA and a .66 WHIP across 13.2 innings.

He spent the year primarily in relief, but the profile does not lock him into that role. The command and pitch mix give him starting rotation potential, while the deception, fastball characteristics, and reliability translate just as effectively to a high-leverage bullpen role. Either path is a viable outcome.